Song
Chocolate Milk
A Dogs in a Pile original · written by Jeremy Holden Kaplan, Brian Patrick Murray.
Played 38 times between 2019 and 2026 — debut Jan 5, 2019 at The Stone Pony, most recently Oct 10, 2026 at Upper Merion Township Building Park — the most recent show. Counted over 716 shows in this archive; the band’s official numbers are on go-set’s page.
38
Times played
36
Shows
5%
of all shows
0
Shows since last played
1 in 19.8
Shows, since debut
11:34
Longest version
5:56
Average length
Length, every timed version
35 timed versions, from 1:36 to 11:34; the band’s own timings from go-set. Ringed dot is the longest. 3 performances carry no timing and sit out.
Year by year
2019 · 5 of 42 shows5
2023 · 2 of 143 shows2
2024 · 13 of 129 shows13
2025 · 10 of 137 shows10
2026 · 8 of 88 shows8
Where it lands in the show
Mid-set34
Show opener2
Set opener1
Set closer1
Comes out of
Segued into the next song 10 of 38 times (26%); arrived by segue 9 times.
Every time played — newest first
DateVenueGapSetLengthSong beforeSong afterNotes
Oct 10, 2026Upper Merion Township Building ParkKing of Prussia, PA0Set 1 · #81:36Mercy, Mercy, Mercy ›› Bugle on the Shelf
Oct 10, 2026Upper Merion Township Building ParkKing of Prussia, PA11Set 1 · #63:33You Didn’t Hear It From Me ›→ Mercy, Mercy, Mercy
Dec 28, 2024Putnam PlaceSaratoga Springs, NY15Set 1 · #711:34Will It Go 'Round In Circles?Little Thingslongest
May 31, 2019Martell's at the Red FoxJeffersonville, VT4Set 2 · #66:03The Other OneBugle on the Shelf
Jan 5, 2019The Stone PonyAsbury Park, NJOne Set · #4Boogie on Reggae WomanThat's What Love Will Make You Dodebut
No fan discussion of Chocolate Milk on go-set yet — be the first.